Quote by Hymer544
good analysis waterman, but do you really think it is possible to do toll-less big trips without getting caught going through many villages/town etc. and getting slowed right down, Ive tended to stay on tolls getting down to the sun the last 10 years. Would consider doing it without tools if I thought it wasnt going to be very frustrating with the stop/start nature on non toll roads? I have an open mind and am willing to be persuaded. We are headin to costa brava from calais in July so I might look in to a toll free route.
It depends on the route and your frame of mind. If all you are thinking about is 'getting there' then its probably not a good idea to take a D route as every little 'delay' will frustrate the hell out of you. If however you are happy to move along, taking in the scenery, stopping for a picnic etc and arrive a couple of hours later, with more money in your pocket, than if you had taken the motorway then why not? See a bit of the country side along the way and all that.
I don't tend to do really high kms in one day in the MH because I wouldn't be that pressed for time. We would tend to break up really long journeys with overnights. But if I was doing the trip that Libby is planning and had to do it all in one day (in the MH) then I would give myself a little more time and take the D. And I'm speaking from experience as I've driven most of that route. In a car not a chance, motorway and 130km all the way.
But my basic point is that I think a lot of people look at the time estimate of the motorway vs a D route but forget to factor in the fact that in a camper you wont do anything near the motorway time estimate. The end result is paying a lot of money to gain very little.
As for your route, now at ~1,300kms that's a whole other ballgame and what really comes into play in your scenario is the amount of time you have. But my starting position would be to take my time on the way up and down and make that part of the holiday. However, if my holiday was all about the Costa Brava then it would be, suck it up folks we're burning diesel
But that really wouldn't be me.
[BTW There can also be horrendous delays on the motorways. And it would certainly frustrate the hell out of me to be paying to sit in a jam.]